Uses of Internet Tools

In Mundane Internet Tools, Mobilizing Practices, and the Coproduction of Citizenship in Political Campaigns, Rasmus Kleis Neilson explains that there are a plethora of Internet tools available that can be used to increase political participation and ultimately the active exercise of citizenship through volunteering for political campaigns.  His
argument centers on the idea that, “specific mundane Internet tools (like email) are much more deeply integrated into mobilizing practices today than the emerging tools (like social networking sites) and specialized tools (like campaign websites),” (2).  In his discussion, he says that emerging and specialized tools may one day become mundane and familiar like email, but they have not become useful in this way because they are still too new and foreign.

Neilson explains that tools are ever changing and what is seen as an emerging tool will one day be viewed as a mundane tool. With that in mind, I think we can say social networking sites are as widely used and familiar as email was back in 2008 – thus pushing them towards the mundane category. Yet, as far as mobilizing people to get involved in an electoral campaign, I am still unsure if social media actually has an impact on how people act as citizens.

When thinking about Clay Shirky’s discussion of the over-estimated the success of the Dean campaign in Existing Deanspace, it is clear that this particular campaign put strong emphasis on the use of emerging tools. The Dean campaign can be looked at as tactically successful, but not strategically successful. Neilson states, “people are simply much more likely to work for a campaign if someone asks them to,” (6). If we think about this, then we can further understand why the Dean campaign failed strategically, and why mundane tools like email may be more effective in mobilizing voters. Clearly the use of emerging tools in the Dean campaign was unsuccessful, leading me to believe emerging and specialized tools might be more tactical and as a result not successful in strategically increasing political participation.

As emerging and specialized tools become more and more mundane, does this necessarily mean they will all be equally as successful in getting people involved? Just because social media is familiar, is it still as effective as other mundane tools? Or are we simply over-estimating the success of social media as a strategic tool – similar to what was done in the Dean campaign?

This entry was posted in Winter 2012. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Uses of Internet Tools

  1. brittanyverner says:

    I think that each tool online has its own purpose and audience. Therefore, while social media may or may not ever be as powerful as email in generating recruits it could still be successful in other ways such as getting out information.

  2. Lauren says:

    The evolution of these tools we use is definitely important to examine and question, just as you did. I think it is too much of a generalization to say that all of the social media tools that are becoming mundane will be effective; rather, each tool will probably serve as different levels of effectiveness at different times. I think it is possible for tools to be very effective when they first become mundane, because it is kind of like, even though they are now part of our everyday lives, they are still new and what we turn to first. However, I can counter myself and say that as time goes on, mundane social media tools may actually become more effective than they were in the first place. By this I mean, as people become more and more used to incorporating such tools into everyday life, they will prove to be more useful. I can see both sides, and think this is definitely something worth further investigation.

  3. I believe that each social media platform that is emerging fulfills a different niche within the globalization of the internet and the sharing of ideas on a global level. so while some technologies may not be as effective in terms of politics, each website or app that becomes available is just another tool for the public to utilize in sharing their lives with the world, which is ultimately what the internet and social media has become.

  4. alexlcraig says:

    I don’t think it necessarily means that the emerging tools will be equally as successful in getting people involved. Not all emerging tools are necessarily mobilizing tools. They could simply be tools for communication and sharing ideas, but not becoming more involved then the first step of the ladder.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s